What it is: A 24-hour waterproof eyeliner with an ultra-smooth glide and rich, creamy pigment that delivers crisp lines or smoky-eye looks.
Formulation Type: Eye Liner
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance.
What Else You Need to Know: This smooth gel eyeliner glides on for tug-free, pigment-packed application. It’s sharpenable for clean precision and gives the perfect playtime to blend, smudge, or buff before setting. Choose from neutral to vibrant shades across eye-catching finishes that are waterline safe and smudgeproof.
Disappointing new version of an eyeliner I have used and loved for years. They reduced the amount significantly and took away the sharpener. Now lasts <1 month when previously lasted >6 months
Read more
SDLliving
Verified Purchase
1w ago
Don’t waste your money
There is no easy way to sharpen this pencil it’s so expensive !! They changed the mechanism and now it won’t twist. Don’t waste your money. They ruined the best eyeliner out there.
Read more
KTynaOD
Green eyes, Fair Light skin tone, Combination skin
1w ago
New update is terrible...lost a faithful customer
AWFUL, bring back the old version! I've been using this for MANY YEARS and the new version is terrible....it no longer has a twist-up sharpener. And it's 1" shorter. It doesn't come with a sharpener, either. I'll be looking for a replacement.
Read more
b77224
Hazel eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Normal skin
Verified Purchase
2w ago
Shrinkflation Victim
I’ve used this eyeliner for years but sadly it is a victim of shrinkflation. I will be retuning it as the new version is 1.5 inches shorter than the last version. Already $30 for an eyeliner! You didn’t need to make it a worse fr
Read more
LeoGrl
Hazel eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
3w ago
not waterproof
it’s the worst eyeliner i’ve ever had, it doesn’t stay on my waterline and when i done doing my makeup i need to reapply also the pencil lead broke, for that price i rather buy smth from drugstore then this
Read more
sonyaxxq
Blue eyes, Fair skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
4w ago
Really happy with liner!
Wears very well in waterlines or on skin. I’ve replaced my usual which was Urban Decay with this one. I bought the mauve color. Highly recommend!
Read more
10Bubba10
Blue eyes, Fair skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
4w ago
transfers and rubs off so bad
i bought this eyeliner after having issues with my other drugstore eyeliner transfering under my eyes and smudging off. to my surprise, this one did the exact same thing, if not even worse especially with this one being 4x the price. insane and not worth it at all!!!
Read more
katie20048
Brown eyes, Fair skin tone, Sensitive skin
4w ago
They need to bring back the original eyeliner this one is a pencil and the other one was so much better I have to find a new brand now
Read more
roxanamaria
Brown eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Normal skin
Verified Purchase
1mo ago
Recommended
It stayed on longer than any tightliner I've had, I didn't even know it was possible for tightliner to stay on that long without reapplication. However I've never had luck sharpening these types of products and I wish they would stop making them, for that reason I dropped 2 stars.
Read more
szakal
Blue eyes, Fair Light skin tone, Dry skin
1mo ago
This eyeliner is not waterproof and it smudges under your eyes almost immediately even with eye primer, powder, another waterproof seal, and setting spray. It doesn’t even last 4 hours.
Read more
HThuyen
Brown eyes, Sensitive skin
What it is: A 24-hour waterproof eyeliner with an ultra-smooth glide and rich, creamy pigment that delivers crisp lines or smoky-eye looks.
Formulation Type: Eye Liner
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance.
What Else You Need to Know: This smooth gel eyeliner glides on for tug-free, pigment-packed application. It’s sharpenable for clean precision and gives the perfect playtime to blend, smudge, or buff before setting. Choose from neutral to vibrant shades across eye-catching finishes that are waterline safe and smudgeproof.
Suggested Usage: Classic Liner: -Line your top lash line from the center of your eyelid to the outer corner. -Complete the line, starting from the inner corner and meeting at the center. -Add intensity by applying on the waterline. -Sharpen as needed.
Easy Wing: -Draw a line right above the lash line, from the center of the eye to the outer corner. -Use an angled brush to quickly blend the line upward and outward—the formula gives you just enough time to smudge before it sets.
Summary
5
4
3
2
1
4.2★
267 Reviews*
79%
Recommended
*Some reviewers received something in exchange for a review (free product, payment, sweeps entry).
