This is the first time I’ve ever bought the same eyeliner twice. It is easy to apply with a lasting color.

I have used this eyeliner since like... 2015. I've tried many different eyeliners but this has the best colour payoff, best precision and best longevity.

This has been my go to for over fifteen years. Solid, dependable and long-lasting. Super pigmented and goes on smoothly. I like to use in conjunction with the skinnier liner to shape the outer edge for a perfect cat eye. The only drawback is the brown formulation - it unfortunately does not hold a candle to the back Stila, which is a shame. They are like two entirely different products.

I was a die hard fan of the Kat Von D tattoo liner until it got discontinued. This is the only eyeliner that has been comparable, the formula and the pitch blackness are *chef’s kiss*. I also love that it doesn’t get diluted after using it on top of eyeshadow. One of my favourites for sure!!

This did not work for me. Pigment is very blotchy and uneven. Going over a line again to try and even out the blotchy color erases even more pigment for some reason. People seem to love this, but I would absolutely not purchase again.

As someone who has always struggled with putting on liquid eyeliner because of my shaky hands, this one makes it so easy. It comes out nicely and stays on ALL DAY. I will never use anything else I can’t believe it took me this long to find it

Absolutely loved it the first time I used it, great colour, went on well, but after 3 weeks it was dried up. I didn’t even use it daily. Very disappointing for this price point. Won’t be buying it again.

Stila Stay All Day has been my reliable go-to for years, but no more! Within hours, it starts smudging and turns itself into messy eyeshadow. Something in the formula has definitely changed.fhdhdhdnddefinito havr

TLDR: Its worth the price if you struggle with eyeliners. I LOVE THIS EYELINER. I have worn it rain or shine, concerts and funerals, heatwaves while walking for 4 hours, blizzards, under and over sunscreen, bare lids & makeup & primers, ive worn it for an hour and ive worn it for over 12 hours. it has NEVER FAILED. ive been using the same bottle since 2022 (I dont wear makeup every day) and It's FINALLY starting to lose about 1% of its pigment. up until last week it still had full pigment and wasnt dry. ive used it with setting spray and without (mostly without, I didnt buy setting spray till june 2025) ive tried name brands that cost the same as this one, ive used drugstore brands from 1 dollar to 20 dollars, waterproof, transfer proof, smudge proof, and this is the one I stuck with. im about to start trying new eyeliners, if I find one ill update my review but if its not updated in a month I went back to this one. (im probably going back to this one, its like dumping a good partner because they like expensive food just to get a bad one because they only eat 45 cent noodle packs) I have written this review 3 times because the website is crashing from how long it is 😭

i’ve been using this for years but find that as of the past year or so, it’s been drying out extremely fast. i just opened a new one and it’s already out like??