What it is: A pro liquid liner formula that provides long-lasting, waterproof definition with an effortless flexible tip.
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens. This product is also vegan and cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: This liquid liner is extremely pigmented and features a super sharp, flexible felt tip for ultimate control. The bulletproof formula grips the lid and is completely smudge-proof for bold and lasting definition.
I just told this eyeliner “I hate you” out loud in my office. Truly don’t understand how it’s so highly rated? Bummed.
Read more
thisisdumbaf
Hazel eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Normal skin
1mo ago
Recommended
The best eyeliner. Hands down.
This eyeliner is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It was not dry at all and glided smoother than any eyeliner I have used. The brush was absolutely perfect and allowed me to make thin lines or thicker. It was not runny like other
eyeliners
Read more
franikin
Brown eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
2mos ago
Do not buy. Please reformulate
This product costs $24 and it smudges horribly, doesn’t last and the applicator tip is too stiff. I don’t recommend. You can get a better eyeliner for 1/4 of the price. Disappointing because the brand has other amazing products but I cannot recommend this
Read more
agentjenga
Brown eyes, Dry skin
Verified Purchase
2mos ago
Absolutely the WORST liquid liner pen I’ve ever used. I’m so annoyed at how much this costs only for precise application to be impossible. You’re better off with a drugstore brand.
Read more
KatrinaMora
Brown eyes, Medium Tan skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
2mos ago
Bad glide, dry and hard to be precise
I just bought this earlier this week. The sample they had in store was so black and the glide was so good. The one I bought and brought home is so dry and hard to draw a line. It skips and drags. I haven’t bought a high end liner in years and this is why. Gonna give it a few more days but I feel like this one will end up being a return. It’s too expensive for it to be this bad :/
Read more
CallMeClaire
Hazel eyes, Fair skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
4mos ago
Used to be my favorite, idk if they changed their ingredients but lately it gets dry within a week
Read more
sofieeee19
Brown eyes, Medium Tan skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
4mos ago
Dry
This eyeliner is terrible, it has me reaching for my old wet and wild from target. It’s very dry and takes forever to get an eye done. I’ve been doing eyeliner for years and this one is by far the worst. Unfortunately missed the return window
Read more
toninoli
Hazel eyes, Fair skin tone, Dry skin
Verified Purchase
5mos ago
Terrible product
I have tried many different brands of liquid eyeliners and this one has by far been the worst. I was able to use it maybe twice without it completely drying out. The brush isn’t precise and difficult to create a clean line.
Read more
KaitMJ
Brown eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Normal skin
Verified Purchase
6mos ago
Faulty Applicator Save your money
I love Makeup by Mario products and have always had a great experience. This eyeliner started out strong for me. Easy to use, liner stayed put with no smudging or flaking, and quick drying. However about a month in the applicator has become extremely flimsy, and to try to line cleanly is impossible. Do not recommend, there are so many better options out there (better than sex applicator has lasted as long as the product). Sephora refused to give me a refund since it was just over 30 days since I purchased, even though the product itself is faulty. They recommended I reach out to Makeup by Mario, which to me is not a reasonable recommendation. Save your time and eyelids.
Read more
Jassy33
Gray eyes, Light skin tone
Verified Purchase
6mos ago
I just bought this yesterday. It was dry to put on and 5 hours later it’s all smudged under my eye even though I didn’t touch it and wore setting spray. Get stila instead.
Read more
Miaalunik
Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
What it is: A pro liquid liner formula that provides long-lasting, waterproof definition with an effortless flexible tip.
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens. This product is also vegan and cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: This liquid liner is extremely pigmented and features a super sharp, flexible felt tip for ultimate control. The bulletproof formula grips the lid and is completely smudge-proof for bold and lasting definition.
Suggested Usage: -In front of a mirror, rest your elbow on a flat surface, and tilt your head up so you have ultimate control for application. -When applying false lashes, use liquid liner as a final step to conceal the lash band.
Summary
5
4
3
2
1
3.6★
226 Reviews*
63%
Recommended
*Some reviewers received something in exchange for a review (free product, payment, sweeps entry).
