I was pleasantly surprised by this eyeliner. Most "waterproof" eyeliners do not actually last in my waterline but this one does! Does it start to fade after a while? Yes, it definitely doesn't maintain the sharp, opaque, freshly applied look. But that's ok to me - usually I smudge out waterline eyeliner to begin with to give it a "lived in" vibe. You do have to work fast to smudge it out because it sets pretty quickly. It's also very waterproof - I cried multiple times while I had this eyeliner on and it didn't bleed. My 1 gripe is the smudgey end. It's way too chonky and stiff, and actually removes the eyeliner entirely, rather than smudges it out. I think a softer, angled brush on the other end would be better. Overall, my 8 hr wear test was successful (for me) and I'm happy I've finally found a solid waterproof eyeliner.

Very nice product and lasts all day I’ve been using this for years but it’s become a bit overpriced

I love this eyeshadow, it goes on so smoothly without having to be concern with sharpening the pencil. It comes with a smudger too. The chocolate brown is perfect for me as I have light skin and very dark hair, but don't want to use black.

NOT worth the super high price, this smudges a lot and gives you raccoon eyes, on top of that it broke like 3 times, until it broke to the bottom and couldn't keep using it. Don't waste your money. LA colors waterproof one was better and I'm not kidding.

The best eyeliner I’ve ever used. Doesn’t smear, it applied perfectly well and last a long time. And if you have allergies to eyeliner pencil, this pencil won’t make your eyes watery. 💦 I ordered two because it’s the BEST!

Not worth your money. Get a NYX one. The brush fell off on the first try. And I gotta press hard to get any color. Only got this because I’m older now and my mom used this makeup line when I was a kid. She hyped it up so much decided to start with eyeliners and already have a bad taste in my mouth.

I have been loving this eyeliner! It is very long lasting and easy to apply on the top and bottom eyelids. Great for tight lining. I’m not quite sure how to use the other end but I use it to clean up - it doesn’t really smudge like I thought.

Glides in and smudges well ! Stays for long periods

This eyeliner glides smoothly without fading. The brown is a rich chocolate color that I love and I also like that it has the little sponge on one end of the pencil to blend the liner.

This is the first waterproof eyeliner pencil that I really like. I’ve tried others at various price point. This goes on smoothly and it stays long. I use eye drops throughout the day, it stays on. That said, I also use an eye primer, which I think helps as well. Every eyeliner, I’ve used previously wind up, sticking to the top of my eyelid as I have put his eyes. This one does not. do use I do you use an eye primer. I do use an eye primer. That said, I do that said, you use an eye primer. I do use an eye primer.