At first it was amazing but it dried out so fast, it’s unusable. So if you’re somehow going to use it up quickly it’s great but yeah…big waste of money.

I love the shade of the brown liner, it looks gorgeous and much less harsh than black liner for when i want a softer look but for my eyes to still pop. I use it for tight lining and it’s sometimes difficult to get it to show up at first. I’ve started drying along my waterline with a q tip and I draw some lines on my hand to warm up the liner and get it going. It lasts a long time as well, if I sleep in my make up (ik bad to do) it will still be on when I wake up. I also love that it has a blending brush it works well and helps clean up and blur the liner to your liking.

Dried out in a few months. Not worth the money. MAC pencils last decades and don’t dry out. I am very disappointed. I wanted to get the black as well but I definitely will not. I tried sharpening and even the blowdryer trick dryer trick. Dry as a rock.

I bought this brand based off the ratings, and im very disappointed with this pencil. It dried out on me after 4 uses….even after sharpening the pencil it still does not glide on my under eyelid smoothly. Im literally on one eye for a minute trying to get full coverage. Don't recommend this brand…However, I do recommend “Makeup by Mario” Pigment Pro Eyeliner! Works amazing! And it doesn't dry out.

Been searching for a replacement for a Lancome French Blue pencil I had like forty years ago. Closest thing to it was Clinique Blue Grey Quickliner and now that is discontinued. You'd think it would be an easy replacement but it's not! This comes closer than anything I've found. Plus this is really a nice pencil.Bit pricey.

It worked great the first two weeks and then had to sharpen it….VERY HARD TO Sharpen. Will not buy again.

It's my second pencil - that's how much I love it. It's the first pencil that doesn't transfer from the tight line to my under eye area, it stats put all day, doesn't irritate eyes. What's not to love? The only con is the very poor color range.

Dries out so fast and does not sharpen well. Expensive and does not “glide in easily” as others have said.

It was great until the pencil dried out and I had to throw away more than half of it away. Also doesn’t sharpen well.

Best eyeliner I’ve found since my former holy grail was discontinued in 2021 (iykyk). Valentino NAILED IT with these, they are absolutely worth the money! They apply effortlessly…not so soft they break or smush, but not hard either. There is no tugging or feathering and the pigment is wonderful. I’m 47 and perimenopausal, so I battle bouts of hot flashes/sweats/tears often and in my experience these don’t migrate, bleed, or transfer once they set. I don’t get any fallout or flecking, they stay put till I wash my face at night. Another bonus is: the brush on the opposite end is actually functional, perfect for blending and smudging while still being gentle on the delicate eye area. Very well designed and thought out. My only wish is, for the price a sharpener would’ve been nice, but I’m still not mad over it ;)